INSTITUTE OF CONDITIONAL CONDEMNATION IN GUIDING BASICS OF CRIMINAL LAW OF THE RSFSR 1919 YEAR: CONCEPTUAL BASES AND HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCE
Abstract
The article carried out a historical excursion of the emergence and formation of the institution of conditional conviction. It has been established that the first sources of Soviet criminal law only mentioned conditional conviction. The procedure for its application and the time frame of the legislator were not determined. For the first time in Russian legislation, the peculiarities of the appointment of a suspended sentence were revealed in the Guidelines on Criminal Law of R.S.F.S.R. 1919. However, despite this, in the science of criminal law, the need to apply the above-mentioned institution was still perceived for some period. In this connection, the author analysed various doctrinal provisions taking into account the understanding of the legislative regulation of the institution of conditional conviction of the Guidelines on Criminal Law of R.S.F.S.R. 1919 and the practice of their application. In addition, a comparative legal analysis of the said source and content of articles 73 and 74 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation was carried out in terms of continuity and prospects for optimization of modern criminal legislation. It was concluded that it is preferable to legislate the definition of suspended conviction in article 73 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.
Keywords
институт уголовного права,
условное осуждение,
преступление,
наказание,
усмотрение суда,
Руководящие начала по уголовному праву РСФСР 1919 г,
меры уголовно-правового характера,
institution of criminal law,
suspended conviction,
crime,
punishment,
measures of criminal-legal nature,
Guidelines on Criminal Law of R.S.F.S.R. 1919,
discretion of the court
References
1. Гогель С.К. О желательности и возможности введения в России института условного осуждения // Журнал Министерства юстиции. Изд-во СПБ. Типография Правительствующего Сената. № 7. 1897. С. 41-62.
2. Доклад Случевского В.К. к IV Международному пенитенциарному конгрессу в Санкт-Петербурге по вопросу о приостановлении исполнения наказания // Сборник исследований и статей по вопросу об условном осуждении. СПб., 1898. С. 308-318.
3. Курс уголовного права. Общая часть. Т. 2: Учение о наказании. Учебник для вузов / под ред. Н.Ф. Кузнецовой, И.М. Тяжковой. М., 2002. 464 с.
4. Пионтковский А.А. Об условном осуждении, или системе испытания. Уголовно-политическое исследование. Одесса, 1984. 191 с.
5. Таганцев Н.С. Русское уголовное право. Лекции. Часть общая. В 2 т. Т. 2. М., 1994. 393 с.
For citations:
Poltavets V.V.
INSTITUTE OF CONDITIONAL CONDEMNATION IN GUIDING BASICS OF CRIMINAL LAW OF THE RSFSR 1919 YEAR: CONCEPTUAL BASES AND HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCE. Legal Bulletin of the Kuban State University. 2020;(1):63-67.
(In Russ.)
Views:
184